Audio Only! October 27, 2007, The Bridge School Benefit, Mountain View, CA
~~Brothers In Arms was originally recorded by Dire Straits in 1985 on the Brothers In Arms album.
I think James love this song and me too. It's not perfect but James is a kind of monster so respect... And i think it kik ass. Vive la France ! and USA
@InvaderTam this consert was for children with severe speech and physical impairments so.....
I get sick
If what people just listened to had been amateurs, like a school band, I doubt many would be commenting. The playing and singing is poor. The guys who make the cover songs for guitarists to play along with do a more professional job.
It's heartening to read many 'Metallica' fans dismiss this as being poor...at least they aren't trying to kid themselves. This should never have got further than the gig they performed it. There own quality control should have killed this off
@InvaderTam their laughing and clapping and cheering because they know of it and their surprised that their favorite band is playing such an amazing song....i'll give knoplfer the credit for bringing the song to the light but the reason why they stay silent is mostly because its the same sounding every time he plays it.
This is like watching an opening scene from a John Carpenter movie. There is no substitute to Mark Knopfler
@riskybusiness53
They just did a cover of a song they love in a benefit concert for a school, we do all know the originals are better very often, but what's the problem? I'm sure you never played other people's song andd you are always composing, right?
Baptisms of FIAH!
rien a voir, mark reste un monstre de feeling, meme a la voix... cette cover est pas du tout a la hauteur de l'original, loin de la...
Metallica shows great respect to Mark Knopfler with their version. I absolutely love both bands / artists.
Dire straits is way better , I don;t like Metallica's red neck voice
there isnt a differance..Dire Straits is not to be topped by metallica they both have there great songs both are the best but at playing ...singing .....feeling" BROTHER IN ARMS" there is only ONE thats Mark Knopfler " DIRE STRAITS" they cant reach them !!!!!!!!!!!!
i listened to the original, then this, and i suprisingly like james voice better
@abnegatingcecity
I agree. The best version except the original is the Northern Kings one, despite the very strong finnish accent.
Don't do this ever again, Metallica can't top Dire Straits.
Nice try though
I concur..this is sacrilege. Why is it that Metallica feels the need to "redo" others music? They tried the same thing with "Turn the page" and it was not near as good as Seger's. Have they lost the creativity to do their own stuff?
it really isn't bad but it really is not good either. lets let mark keep on keeping on !
@2Spillner2 NOOOOOOO please tell me this is a bad dream!!! To me this is blasphemy!!
I couldn't agree more. Thumb DOWN!!!
the best cover of this song is from the amazing Northern Kings, that part using the score of "saving private Ryan" simply amazing
I must agree... I did like Metallica's version, and I'm a big fan of theirs, but Mark Knopfler's is worth crying. Simply that.
I'm a huge Metallica fan and have got all their albums. I didn't really like the way James performed this song though. Knopfler's version is the best, no doubt.
@2Spillner2
none can reach mark knopfler's skills on his guitar,ur right.
Even the the voice !!! i prefer the original.
Anyway Metallica is a Exellent band in his genre and they should stay in it.
thumb down. reason:
cause mark knopfler is the best and nobody can play his songs as good. Metallica is a excellent band. But this sounds horrible... SORRY
I'm huge fan of dIRE sTRAITS and M.Knopfler ...and also big fan of Metallica \m/ ...but this sux ass ..knopfler is something else..his has more soul.
No, no, no, no! Please, Metallica, while I still have some respect for you, please. Mark Knopfler is off limits.
コメント
I think James love this song and me too. It's not perfect but James is a kind of monster so respect... And i think it kik ass. Vive la France ! and USA
@InvaderTam this consert was for children with severe speech and physical impairments so.....
I get sick
If what people just listened to had been amateurs, like a school band, I doubt many would be commenting. The playing and singing is poor. The guys who make the cover songs for guitarists to play along with do a more professional job. It's heartening to read many 'Metallica' fans dismiss this as being poor...at least they aren't trying to kid themselves. This should never have got further than the gig they performed it. There own quality control should have killed this off
@InvaderTam their laughing and clapping and cheering because they know of it and their surprised that their favorite band is playing such an amazing song....i'll give knoplfer the credit for bringing the song to the light but the reason why they stay silent is mostly because its the same sounding every time he plays it.
This is like watching an opening scene from a John Carpenter movie. There is no substitute to Mark Knopfler
@riskybusiness53 They just did a cover of a song they love in a benefit concert for a school, we do all know the originals are better very often, but what's the problem? I'm sure you never played other people's song andd you are always composing, right?
Baptisms of FIAH!
rien a voir, mark reste un monstre de feeling, meme a la voix... cette cover est pas du tout a la hauteur de l'original, loin de la...
Metallica shows great respect to Mark Knopfler with their version. I absolutely love both bands / artists.
Dire straits is way better , I don;t like Metallica's red neck voice
there isnt a differance..Dire Straits is not to be topped by metallica they both have there great songs both are the best but at playing ...singing .....feeling" BROTHER IN ARMS" there is only ONE thats Mark Knopfler " DIRE STRAITS" they cant reach them !!!!!!!!!!!!
i listened to the original, then this, and i suprisingly like james voice better
@abnegatingcecity I agree. The best version except the original is the Northern Kings one, despite the very strong finnish accent.
Don't do this ever again, Metallica can't top Dire Straits. Nice try though
I concur..this is sacrilege. Why is it that Metallica feels the need to "redo" others music? They tried the same thing with "Turn the page" and it was not near as good as Seger's. Have they lost the creativity to do their own stuff?
it really isn't bad but it really is not good either. lets let mark keep on keeping on !
@2Spillner2 NOOOOOOO please tell me this is a bad dream!!! To me this is blasphemy!! I couldn't agree more. Thumb DOWN!!!
the best cover of this song is from the amazing Northern Kings, that part using the score of "saving private Ryan" simply amazing
I must agree... I did like Metallica's version, and I'm a big fan of theirs, but Mark Knopfler's is worth crying. Simply that.
I'm a huge Metallica fan and have got all their albums. I didn't really like the way James performed this song though. Knopfler's version is the best, no doubt.
@2Spillner2 none can reach mark knopfler's skills on his guitar,ur right. Even the the voice !!! i prefer the original. Anyway Metallica is a Exellent band in his genre and they should stay in it.
thumb down. reason: cause mark knopfler is the best and nobody can play his songs as good. Metallica is a excellent band. But this sounds horrible... SORRY
I'm huge fan of dIRE sTRAITS and M.Knopfler ...and also big fan of Metallica \m/ ...but this sux ass ..knopfler is something else..his has more soul.
No, no, no, no! Please, Metallica, while I still have some respect for you, please. Mark Knopfler is off limits.